When you are given the option to renovate your cave, your choice between mushrooms or bats Stardew Valley rather takes it seriously. Both mushrooms and bats give you important advantages, as health elixirs are made from the mushrooms that may be found all across the Stardew universe, and on the other hand, using fruit bats to create artisanal goods can be a fantastic choice. Even when it is out of season, the bats will provide you with a slow but consistent supply of fruits.
In this article, we are going to explain the pros and cons of each option and enable you to make your preference by knowing the advantages of your choice. So let’s dive in.
Mushrooms or bats Stardew Valley cave production
Once you have 25,000G in Stardew Valley, a man by the name of Demitrius will show up. This charming man will give you the option of converting your cave into a residence for fruit-producing bats or a garden for some priceless mushrooms. Also, if you are in search of alternative relaxing but profound games, check out: 10 best video games to unwind after college
So, which one should you choose, and why?
Benefits of a mushroom cave
Firstly and most importantly, mushrooms enable you to make life elixirs. Life elixirs are without a doubt a priceless resource, making them crucial from the start of the game to the final finish. Don’t worry if you don’t know how to make Life Elixirs, though; once you’ve earned fighting skills level 2, you can start making these by using any one (1) of the following:
- Purple Mushroom
- Red Mushroom
- Chanterelle
- Morel
It is important to keep in mind that the items listed above are hard to come by in the game, therefore mushrooms are a crucial way to get elixirs.
Also, mushrooms can be trusted. It will place six planters in the cave after you have a mushroom cave filled with mushrooms, producing six mushrooms each day. If you have earned the Fighting skill, it is extremely likely that the more uncommon varieties of mushrooms, such as morels and purple caps, can be employed in elixir’s life (at level 2). One red, purple, morel, and chanterelle mushroom is required for life elixirs.
Another advantage they have is that mushrooms are one of the best and most valuable crops. Interestingly, the Great Mushroom Tree offers common, red, and purple mushrooms in contrast to the option of the Mushroom Cave. The only way to have mushrooms without having to actively collect them on your own time is through the mushroom option.
How about fruit bats?
Every day, different fruits will appear on the cave floor if fruit bats are permitted to stay in your cave.
The quantity of fruit within affects how quickly new fruit will spawn. For instance, there will be a 48% chance of new fruit spawning if the cave is empty. If there is just one fruit within the cave, the probability drops to 25%, to 13% with two fruits, and to 7% with three or more fruits. All of the fruit, along with their possibilities of dropping and selling price, are listed below:
| Fruit | Chance to Spawn | Sell Price (Normal Quality) |
|---|---|---|
| Cherry | 3.6% | 80g |
| Pomegranate | 3.6% | 140g |
| Peach | 3.6% | 140g |
| Apple | 2% | 100g |
| Orange | 3.6% | 100g |
| Spice Berry | 20% | 80g |
| Apricot | 3.6% | 50g |
| Wild Plum | 20% | 80g |
| Blackberry | 20% | 20g |
| Salmonberry | 20% | 5g |
Similar to mushrooms, the Community Center requires bundles of all the fruit you can discover in the cave (salmonberries are an exception).
Fruits also make wonderful presents for villages. Fruit is a generally well-received present. You can strengthen your relationships with the villagers if you provide them with fruit on a regular basis.
Therefore, if you are having difficulty while choosing mushrooms or bats Stardew Valley suggests that you should go with bats if f you are looking forward to becoming the candy of the town and with mushrooms if there are fights ahead of you. In case you have more detailed questions about the game, you can always visit Stardew Valley’s website and learn pretty much anything about the game.
