The Sony PlayStation Store lawsuit has taken a step forward. The London Tribunal’s recent decision to push ahead with the lawsuit is making waves in the gaming world. The core allegation revolves around claims that Sony’s PlayStation Store practices are hitting players with inflated charges. Despite pushback from PS5 creators, this ruling opens the door to a potential game-changer, with UK players possibly looking at a whopping $7.9 billion payout.
Sony PlayStation Store lawsuit details
The Sony PlayStation Store lawsuit drama kicked off in August last year, accusing Sony of anti-competitive conduct. The spotlight is on Sony’s 30 percent commission on all PlayStation Store sales, with the claim arguing it prevents potential cost savings for consumers. Sony’s bid to shut down the case hit a stumbling block as the Competition Appeal Tribunal ruled against them. The tribunal underlined Sony’s failure to convincingly prove the case was baseless or destined to fail in a trial.
PlayStation State of Play September 2023: Biggest announcements
Consumer advocate Alex Neill is at the helm of this legal battle, and the stage is set for a showdown as both parties gear up for the next phase. It’s essential to note that Sony isn’t being accused of sneaky price maneuvers. Instead, the lawsuit challenges a widespread industry practice—charging fees while keeping competitors out. The crux of the matter is that by limiting third-party sales on the PlayStation Store, Sony is curbing fair competition, resulting in higher prices for gamers.
“In relation to the Two Sided Market Issue, the Tribunal was satisfied that the PCR met the requirement for a sufficiently credible and plausible methodology, as far as necessary for the grant of a CPO. The Tribunal noted that it is important to recognise that these proceedings are at an early stage and there is a degree of asymmetry between the knowledge of the PCR and its team and the knowledge of Sony, as owner of the PlayStation system. In respect of the Excessive Pricing Issue, the Tribunal was satisfied that the PCR had met the requirement for an adequate methodology in relation to this point, at least as far as necessary for the grant of a CPO,” the claim read.
A global trend: Connecting the dots with U.S. cases
This legal clash echoes familiar disputes in the United States, especially the Epic vs. Apple lawsuit and the ongoing Epic vs. Google court trial. Epic Games, the brains behind Fortnite, took a swing at both the App Store and Google Play for slapping hefty commissions on businesses. To simplify, imagine if your PC could only run Steam, and Valve’s storefront was the exclusive hub for games. Similar arguments in U.S. courts faced resistance. The big question is whether the Sony lawsuit in the UK will carve out a different path.
Sony is bringing PS5 games to your hand with PlayStation Portal for $199.99
Kotaku draws parallels between the Sony case and its U.S. counterparts, specifically the Epic vs. Apple lawsuit and the ongoing Epic vs. Google court trial. Epic Games threw shade at the App Store and Google Play for charging hefty commissions to businesses. Picture a world where your PC could only use Steam, and Valve’s store held the keys to all games. These arguments haven’t gained much traction in U.S. courts, leaving the outcome of the Sony lawsuit in the UK up in the air, says Gamelevate. Only time will reveal if it takes a different turn.
Featured image credit: Laura Heimann/Unsplash
